turner-mitchell

Sixth Judicial District Judge Mitchell Turner

TownNews.com Content Exchange

IOWA CITY — Abortion rights advocates Monday asked a judge to temporarily block a law that, starting Wednesday, requires any Iowa woman seeking an abortion to wait 24 hours.

Alice Clapman, an attorney for Planned Parenthood of the Heartland, argued the waiting period would require pregnant women to make two trips to a provider, which could increase the medical risk depending on far along the woman is in the pregnancy, which must to performed in the first 20 weeks of pregnancy in Iowa.

Many patients have to travel hours to receive abortion services because there are only six providers in the state, Clapman said during a phone conference hearing in Johnson County District Court. If patients require a procedure instead of a medical abortion, there are only two clinics in the state — Iowa City and Des Moines.

Assistant Iowa Attorney General Thomas Ogden, arguing for the state, said the petitioners were asserting constitutional rights that don’t belong to them. Planned Parenthood has no standing — or legal rights — to make the claims, he said.

Clapman also argued the measure violates a “single subject rule” of bills in the Legislature because the last-minute addition of the waiting period wasn’t “germane” to the rest of House File 594.

The purpose of the single subject rule is to prevent lawmakers — and voters — from being surprised by what is included in one piece of legislation.

Planned Parenthood asked for a temporary injunction while this case is further litigated.

Sixth Judicial District Judge Mitchell Turner questioned Ogden on that timing. According to the information he said he read about the bill, he didn’t know if “abortion” was mentioned in the title before 10:18 p.m. that night. The bill passed the Iowa House 40 minutes later.

It went to the Iowa Senate and passed about 4 a.m. without public debate. Most Iowans were probably asleep by then, he noted.

Ogden said it’s not uncommon that bills are passed at the last minute.

Turner noted there were other abortion bills introduced in the 2020 session that were subject to public debate — but none passed. He said it seemed like lawmakers didn’t want to pass an abortion bill.

Ogden said this one may have been a higher priority than the others.

But legislators knew a similar bill was struck down two years ago. The judge said it now gave him “pause” because he would be telling the Iowa Supreme Court it got that decision wrong.

Turner pointed out a U.S. Supreme Court ruling made early Monday was also regarding third-party representation — this one allowing medical providers to assert rights on behalf of patients.

“Doesn’t that answer the question?” he asked.

Ogden said this petition is a state court claim, and a state court hasn’t made a ruling on third party standing.

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds signed the bill Monday afternoon. It will become law Wednesday unless Turner grants the emergency injunction.

He said he would make a ruling on an injunction soon.

This article originally ran on wcfcourier.com.

Locations

TownNews.com Content Exchange
Load comments